World's Fair 2024
How to Construct Domain Specific LLM Evaluation Systems: Hamel Husain and Emil Sedgh
Overview
This talk outlines a systematic approach to constructing domain-specific LLM evaluation systems. It emphasizes the importance of moving beyond initial "vibe checks" and prompt engineering to establish a robust framework for consistent AI improvement. The core thesis is that a well-defined evaluation system, built on foundational principles, is crucial for developing production-ready AI applications and unlocking advanced capabilities like fine-tuning.
Who should watch
- AI Engineers
- Product Managers
- Builders working with LLMs
- Those struggling to measure or improve AI performance
- Teams looking to move from MVP to production-ready AI
Key takeaways
- Start with fundamental unit tests and assertions based on observed failure modes, rather than immediately jumping to complex tools or LLM-as-a-judge.
- Log evaluation results to a database and visualize them using existing tools (like Metabase) to track progress and identify trends.
- Prioritize looking at your data by building or utilizing tools that minimize friction, even if it means creating custom data viewing and annotation applications.
- Synthetically generate test cases using LLMs to bootstrap input data, especially when user data is scarce.
- Iteratively improve AI through prompt engineering within your evaluation framework to debug and gain confidence in your system.
- A comprehensive evaluation system enables efficient data curation for fine-tuning by filtering good cases and providing workflows for failed ones.
- When using LLM-as-a-judge, ensure alignment with human judgment through careful labeling and iteration to build trust in the LLM's evaluations.
- Avoid common pitfalls such as focusing on tools over processes, relying on generic evaluations, and using LLM-as-a-judge prematurely.
Notable quotes
*If you don't have a way of measuring progress you can't really build.*
*It's really critical to your overall evaluation system if you can have them and how do you run the assertions one very reasonable way is to use CI.*
*The most important part if you remember anything from this talk it is you need to look at your data and you need to fight as hard as you can to remove all friction in looking at your data.*
Unofficial community note. Prefer the recording for nuance.